The High Court and coroner's court have examined competing legal arguments regarding the scope of verdicts available to the jury in the resumed inquest into the 48 deaths at the Stardust nightclub fire. The new inquests, which commenced in April 2023 at the Rotunda Hospital in Dublin, followed a 2019 direction by the then Attorney General that fresh proceedings were necessary due to insufficient examination of the fire's circumstances at the original 1982 inquiry. Former Stardust manager Eamon Butterly challenged the coroner's decision to permit a potential unlawful killing verdict, arguing it would identify him as subject to censure. In November 2022, Mr Justice Charles Meenan rejected this challenge, confirming such a verdict could lawfully be available provided no individual remained identifiable as censurable. Following the conclusion of evidence, Coroner Dr Myra Cullinane received further submissions from interested parties. She ultimately ruled that an unlawful killing verdict could be placed before the jury, applying a beyond-reasonable-doubt standard of proof. The available verdicts were determined as accidental death, misadventure, unlawful killing, narrative, and open verdict.
Source links
Original report plus public source leads and related archive reports used for review context.
Public source leads
- What the Stardust jury didn’t hear, and the legal battles behind the inquest - Irish Independent Irish Independent · Thu, 18 Apr 2024 07:00:00 GMT
Related court reports
-
Stardust inquest may run until end of year, with over 300 witnesses expected
Courts News Ireland · 2023-05-23
The inquest into the Stardust fire of February 1981, in which 48 young people died, entered a new phase at Dublin Coroner's Court on 23 May 2023. Coroner Dr Myra...
-
Archaeologist was stabbed 17 times, murder trial hears
Courts News Ireland · 2015-02-12
A murder trial at the Central Criminal Court heard that archaeologist Emmett Connolly sustained 17 stab wounds during an incident at a house in Cootehill, County Cavan...
-
Jury to begin deliberating in trial of childminder charged with assaulting baby
Courts News Ireland · 2015-06-23
A jury at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court will begin deliberating tomorrow in the trial of a childminder charged with assaulting a ten-month-old baby. Sandra Higgins,...
-
Widower of murdered mum Sylvia Roche Kelly has damages action against the State struck out
Courts News Ireland · 2015-01-23
The High Court has struck out a damages action brought by Lorcan Roche Kelly against the State following the murder of his wife, Sylvia Roche Kelly, in December 2007....
-
Housing agency has more onerous lending criteria than those issued by Minister, lawyers tell discrimination hearing
Courts News Ireland · 2024-12-04
An Indian national living in County Cavan has brought complaints of discrimination against the State's Housing Agency at the Workplace Relations Commission, alleging...