A 63-year-old Dublin man who was seen as the 'cool older cousin' by six children he groomed and sexually assaulted has been jailed for seven years. The man pleaded guilty to 10 sample counts of indecent and sexual assaults, which occurred between 1983 and 1990, and again in 2000. The abuse took place at his family homes in Dublin and Cork. The victims, who were his cousins and a cousin of a cousin, described the abuse as 'shameless exploitation.' Judge Orla Crowe noted the predatory nature of the offences and the breach of trust. One of the victims, who was aged nine to 11 when the abuse occurred, described being frozen in fear and feeling guilty for years. The court heard that the defendant had previously received a suspended sentence in 2005 for sexual assault. Judge Crowe set a headline sentence of nine years but reduced it to seven years, taking into account the defendant's remorse and health issues. The victims' impact statements highlighted the lasting trauma and the breakdown of family relationships.
A motorist who dragged a garda during a chase, leaving him with multiple injuries, has been given a suspended five-year sentence. Dylan Walsh (33) pleaded guilty to endangerment, damaging a garda vehicle, and driving without insurance. The incident occurred in May 2024 when Walsh, who was intoxicated and suffering from mental health issues, refused to stop for gardai and dragged one of them for six meters before ejecting him. The garda sustained injuries to his arm, neck, head, and elbow and was out of work for five months. Judge Pauline Codd noted the aggravating factor of the charge being against a garda and the serious injuries sustained. Walsh has 12 previous convictions, mainly for road traffic offences. The judge took into account his mental health issues, his remorse, and the Probation Service's report indicating a medium risk of re-offending. Walsh was ordered to be disqualified from driving for 10 years and to engage with the Probation Service for three years. The injured garda described significant financial and psychological effects, and his career path has changed due to the incident.
A 36-year-old man who raped his former partner in a hotel room and threatened to gouge her eyeball out with a spoon has been jailed for nine years. The Central Criminal Court heard that the victim was left fearing for her life. The man was convicted of sexual assault, rape, and threats to kill the woman at a Dublin hotel. He has over 70 previous convictions, but no prior sexual offence convictions. Mr Justice Paul Burns noted the intimate relationship between the pair was an aggravating factor and described the rape as 'appalling'. He imposed a headline sentence of 11 years, but suspended the final year for three years on condition the man remains under probation and undertakes recommended courses. The victim described how the crimes changed her life and left her in fear for her life. The man denied all offending at interview and initially claimed they had not had sex in the hotel. In her victim impact statement, the woman said she had washed her skin with bleach and was terrified to socialise.
A drunk man who was found asleep halfway out of a car in a church car park and later urinated in a station cell has had his three-month jail term fully suspended on appeal. Ross Giffney (37) was convicted of obstruction of a peace officer, using threatening language, and criminal damage for urinating in the custody area. He was sentenced to four months in custody with one month suspended. On appeal, Judge James O'Donoghue decided to fully suspend the sentence for two years, telling Giffney that if he stepped out of line, the sentence would be activated. The judge also said Giffney must pay the invoice for the cleaning of the garda cell. Defence counsel said her client was remorseful for his actions and had drink on him on the night. Garda Ben Grimes told the court that Giffney had to be roused from sleep by gardai and that he was a danger to himself and others.
A repeat sex offender, Randi Gladstone, has argued that his trial was unfair after he was forced to withdraw his claims of good character, which led to the jury being informed of his previous convictions for serious offences. Gladstone was convicted in January last year of rape, sexual assault, and false imprisonment in a holiday complex in Co Dublin. He had previously been deported from the UK and had 19 prior convictions, including rape and kidnapping. Gladstone's legal team argued that the trial judge's clarification on false imprisonment and the introduction of his previous convictions unfairly prejudiced his case. The court heard that Gladstone lured an 18-year-old woman into his room, where he raped and falsely imprisoned her. The appeal will be heard by a three-judge court, with a decision expected on March 10. Randi Gladstone pleaded not guilty.
A man found with cocaine worth €100,000 was selling the drug to repay "sinister parties" who had used a pipe bomb to intimidate him after he racked up gambling debts in the hundreds of thousands of Euro, Dublin Circuit Criminal Court has heard. Craig Harris (34) came forward from the District Court on signed pleas to possession of cocaine for sale or supply. He received a five-year sentence from Judge Pauline Codd in July 2023 with four years suspended. When gardai searched his home, a pipe bomb was found near Harris's car. Judge Codd accepted evidence that Harris owed money to other sinister parties and acknowledged that the father of three fully co-operated with the garda investigation and expressed remorse and shame for his involvement in the offence. She said that Harris's gambling addiction was the root cause of the offending but that it did not justify the lengths he went to in order to support that habit. Harris was sentenced to 10 years in prison with the final two years suspended.
A driver who tailgated a stolen motorbike, leading to a fatal collision, has been jailed for three years. Andres Grans De Lima Sores (38) pleaded guilty to careless driving causing the death of Calvin Gilchrist (19) and failing to remain at the scene. The incident occurred on Finglas Road, Dublin, when Sores, driving a car, tailgated the motorbike for nearly 500 metres. Both vehicles crossed to the wrong side of the road, and an oncoming taxi attempted to avoid the collision but was involved in a crash with the motorbike. Mr. Gilchrist sustained serious cranial injuries and died in hospital. Sores fled the scene and was identified months later through CCTV footage. The court heard that Mr. Gilchrist was riding a stolen motorbike without a helmet, and his actions contributed to the tragedy. Judge Pauline Codd noted the serious nature of the case and the impact on Mr. Gilchrist's family, who expressed deep sorrow over his loss. Sores was also banned from driving for seven years and received a suspended sentence for leaving the scene.
A dentist who defrauded the HSE of €58,000 over 17 years has been jailed for one year and ordered to pay €100,000. Jerome Kiely (47) pleaded guilty to multiple counts of deception, including one sample count of dishonestly inducing the HSE to provide a payment for dentures. The court heard that Kiely had two bank accounts containing over €1.5 million, which were frozen. Judge Martin Nolan noted that Kiely had mental health issues and a history of depression, and his wife asked the court not to jail him. Despite this, the judge imposed a three-year sentence, with two years suspended, and ordered Kiely to pay €100,000 to the HSE. The judge acknowledged Kiely's remorse and his good work history but emphasized the seriousness of the case. Kiely's reputation as a dentist has been destroyed, and the court noted that he may not be able to practice again.
Twin brothers Sean Farrell and Eric Farrell, aged 21, appeared before the Central Criminal Court on a charge of murder relating to the death of Ionel Nicolae Diaconu in Tallaght, Dublin 24, on December 11, 2023. Both defendants pleaded not guilty to the murder charge but guilty to the lesser offence of manslaughter. The Director of Public Prosecutions accepted that the manslaughter pleas met the case. Defence counsel noted that the brothers were 19 at the time of the incident and have no significant previous convictions, requesting the court to consider probation reports. The defendants are currently held in custody at Castlerea Prison. Mr Justice Paul McDermott adjourned the matter to May 18 for a sentence hearing and ordered the preparation of two probation reports. The judge remanded the Farrell twins in custody until that date. Regarding the victim's family, prosecution counsel stated that Mr Diaconu's relatives do not live in Ireland and have previously attended proceedings remotely. The court did not record a final conviction or sentence at this stage, as the case remains adjourned for sentencing.
Sammy Hutch (50), a member of the Hutch family who is not involved in gangland activities, has been jailed for six additional years for possessing an improvised pipe bomb. Hutch, who is currently serving a six-and-a-half-year sentence for robbery, was caught by gardai in April 2024 with the device at his home. The bomb was found to be ready to use, and the court heard that Hutch had texted an accomplice about attaching it to gas meters. Judge Patricia Ryan noted the aggravating factors, including the nature of the device and the alleged unlawful purpose. Hutch has 103 previous convictions, including burglary, theft, and drug-related offences. His defence highlighted his long history of drug abuse and his efforts to get clean. The judge reduced the headline sentence of nine years to six years, which will run consecutive to his existing sentence. Hutch's family and a letter from a local horse and pony club were presented in court, and legal aid was requested for an appeal.
A 4'10" creche worker who said her employer stopped rostering her because she needed a step to reach the nappy changing table has lost a workplace safety case. Rosaria Wada Fulguera Tenorio, a Bolivian national on a student visa, worked at the Dublin creche group from March to October 2024, when she said she was taken off the roster and told her workplace was "overstaffed". In her evidence, Ms Fulguera Tenorio said that because of her height, 147cm, or 4'10", she was getting back pain due to the height of the furniture in the baby room. She said she wanted to find a solution that would let her do the job, and that her previous employers had assisted her by providing "a small step" as an accommodation. Links Childcare refused the request in April 2024 on the basis it would be a trip hazard. Instead, her employer ordered her to stop changing nappies and have her colleagues do it instead. Ms Fulguera Tenorio said this led to tension with her co-workers and that she was left feeling "humiliated".
Sean McGovern, 39, appeared by video-link from Portlaoise Prison before the Special Criminal Court, where he is accused of the murder of Noel Kirwan on December 22, 2016, at St Ronan's Drive, Clondalkin, Dublin. The accused, who has a previous address at Kildare Road, Crumlin, Dublin 12, also faces charges of directing the activities of a criminal organisation in connection with that murder between October 20 and December 22, 2016. Additional allegations include directing a criminal organisation regarding the surveillance of James Gately between October 17, 2015, and April 6, 2017, and facilitating a criminal organisation in a conspiracy to murder Mr. Gately. During the trial proceedings, his barrister, Sean Guerin SC, stated that significant work had been completed between legal parties and suggested the case might not ultimately require a trial date, though he could not confirm this immediately. Ms Justice Karen O'Connor, presiding over the three-judge, non-jury court, adjourned the matter to March 16 for an update. No plea, finding, or sentence was recorded at this stage, and the matter remains ongoing.
Shane Murphy, a 36-year-old man with a history of 60 previous convictions, had his six-month jail sentence overturned on appeal and replaced with a fully suspended sentence. Murphy was convicted of theft and threatening behavior after stealing wine from a crêperie and later using threatening language in public. His defense argued that the original sentence was unduly severe, citing his engagement with homeless support and detox programs. The court acknowledged his difficult circumstances but noted his extensive criminal history. Judge James O'Donoghue suspended the sentence for two years, with conditions that Murphy must enter probation, seek rehabilitation if needed, and avoid alcohol. The judge warned that if Murphy failed to comply, he would serve the full nine-month sentence. The appeal highlighted the need for a balanced approach to sentencing, considering both the severity of the offenses and the defendant's efforts at rehabilitation.
A Knockmore man has been sentenced to four years in prison at Castlebar Circuit Court for offences including the savage mauling of a woman by his unmuzzled dog. David Barrett, aged 41, pleaded guilty to assault causing harm following an attack on November 20th, 2022, at Mount Falcon estate. The victim sustained life-changing injuries including severe lacerations and puncture wounds requiring emergency surgery and ongoing treatment. Judge Eoin Garavan noted the dog had been wandering loose and described Barrett's casual attitude toward the danger posed to the public. Barrett also pleaded guilty to assaulting two female gardaí who attended his home in July 2024 whilst responding to a domestic disturbance report. The court heard he was heavily intoxicated and attacked both officers with violence. The global sentence comprised two years for the dog attack and three years for assaulting the gardaí, with the final year suspended. Barrett was ordered to engage in mental health services, substance addiction treatment, and probation supervision upon release.
TikTok has been granted permission by the High Court to redact sensitive information from confidential documents used in its appeal against a €530 million fine imposed by the Data Protection Commissioner (DPC) over Chinese access to user data. The court heard that both parties had agreed on categories of information to be redacted, which included commercially, technically, and financially sensitive details. The appeal involves 6,000 pages of documentation, and the redactions are intended to protect TikTok from competitive and security risks. The DPC has been granted the right to apply to the court if they have future objections to the redactions. The court has maintained a stay on the fine, with the appeal set to proceed on March 3. The DPC's fine was based on the company's failure to prevent Chinese engineers from accessing user data, despite assurances that data from the European Economic Area is not stored in China. TikTok argues that the DPC breached fair procedures in its decision and failed to consider key evidence.
Dylan Mangan, the lead assailant in an extortion plot, failed to convince the Court of Appeal to reduce his five-year sentence for threatening two victims with violence and demanding €20,000. Mangan, who has 18 previous convictions, was identified through CCTV and was in possession of a phone used to contact the victims. His defense argued that the sentencing judge failed to consider the principle of parity with his co-accused, Des Smyth, who received a four-year sentence with part suspended. The Court of Appeal rejected the appeal, noting that Mangan's level of involvement was significantly greater than Smyth's and that the judge had a rational basis for the disparity in sentences. The court emphasized that Mangan was the principal perpetrator and had a more substantial criminal history. The threats involved slitting the throats of children and burning down homes, with the victims having no connection to the drug debt. The appeal was dismissed, with the court upholding the original sentence. Dylan Mangan pleaded guilty. Des Smyth pleaded guilty.
A woman who alleges she was sexually abused by seven of her family members has completed giving evidence after over three months in the witness box. Ms Justice Caroline Biggs expressed gratitude to the woman for her three and a half months of answering questions. The woman began giving evidence via video link in October and provided her testimony to prosecution counsel before being cross-examined by seven defence counsel representing the accused men. Roisin Lacey SC, prosecuting, informed the woman that the prosecution would not be re-examining her. The trial, which began four and a half months ago, is now entering a new phase with further four weeks of evidence expected. Seven men, aged between 32 and 55, are on trial for 103 charges, with 98 counts related to the main complainant. They are her four younger brothers and three uncles, accused of sexually abusing her over a 17-year period between 1996 and 2013. The woman gave evidence via video-link with the assistance of interpreters and an intermediary. Charts and symbols were used to help her communicate. The unnamed 55-year-old pleaded not guilty.
Jason Whelan and Vivian Hanley, a couple with a history of drug use and debt, pleaded guilty to possessing over €230,000 worth of drugs at their home in Finglas. They admitted to being under duress and fear due to threats, and the drugs did not belong to them. Hanley, who has 15 previous convictions for road traffic offenses, has taken steps to address her drug addiction and is now in education and employment. Whelan, who became addicted to cocaine during lockdown, claims to be clean and has a work history. The court acknowledged their vulnerable positions and the threats they faced, adjourning sentencing until May for a probation report and urine analysis. The judge considered the possibility of deviating from the mandatory minimum sentence of 10 years, given their low position in the drug world and their efforts to improve their lives.
A man accused of falsely imprisoning and strangling a woman had his bail revoked after refusing to sign on at Pearse Street Garda Station, claiming the conditions there infringe his human rights. Elric Kibangou Diansa (36), originally from France and residing in Dublin since November 2024, had previously been granted bail for charges of false imprisonment and intentionally or recklessly strangling a woman on June 20, 2025. Gardaí had objected to bail under the O'Callaghan principles, citing the seriousness of the charges, the alleged breach of bail conditions, and concerns about possible interference with the injured party. The court heard that Mr Kibangou Diansa had not provided a new address and was believed to be couch surfing. He stated he stopped signing on because he was required to wait between two-and-a-half and three hours at Pearse Street Garda Station, which he described as overcrowded and dirty, with vomit on the floor and drunk people spitting in the waiting area. He claimed it was a breach of his human rights and civil liberties.
A 72-year-old man from Castleblayney, County Monaghan, has had his eight-year prison sentence reduced to six and a half years following a successful appeal at the Court of Appeal. The man pleaded guilty to fifteen counts of indecent assault against three of his siblings, commencing in the 1970s and 1980s when the victims were aged between nine and fourteen. The original sentencing judge imposed consecutive sentences to reflect the serious and persistent nature of the offending. However, Ms Justice Isobel Kennedy found an error in principle, stating it was not apparent the totality principle had been properly applied. The court quashed the original sentence and resentenced accordingly. The three victims waived their right to anonymity in impact statements describing their upbringing as a "house of horrors.
Alan Vial and Nikita Burns, who were convicted in March 2025 of murdering Robert Robin Wilkin at Sliabh Liag in County Donegal, have been granted a hearing date for their conviction appeals. Vial, aged 39, of Drumanoo Head, Killybegs, and Burns, aged 23, of Carrick, had pleaded not guilty to the charge relating to events on 25 June 2023. A jury rejected their competing accounts of responsibility for the death. The Court of Appeal, presided over by Ms Justice Isobel Kennedy, listed the matter for case management on 20 February and set 23 July for the full hearing of appeals, which is expected to occupy one day. The victim's body was recovered from the sea eight days after the incident.
Paul Rowland was convicted of strangling his then-partner at her home in County Carlow in January 2025. The woman testified that Rowland, who was intoxicated, grabbed her by the neck and strangled her, causing her to fear for her life. She managed to escape and barricaded herself and her son in a bedroom before contacting the gardaí. Rowland was found not guilty of the two assault charges but was convicted of the strangulation charge. The court heard that Rowland had previously tripped the woman and pushed a pool table into her, causing injuries. The jury deliberated for nearly three hours before convicting him. Rowland was remanded in custody for sentencing in March. The court acknowledged the woman's account of the incident and the severity of the strangulation charge, which was a new offense added to the Non-fatal Offences Against The Person Act in 2023. Rowland denied the allegations and claimed he was not intoxicated, but the gardaí confirmed he was unfit for questioning due to his level of intoxication.
A serial offender, Joe Curtin, has been remanded in custody pending sentencing for a mugging and two attempted robberies in Carlow town. Curtin, who has 75 previous convictions, admitted to the crimes in court. The incidents occurred within ten minutes of each other in Hanover Park at 8:30 pm. The first victim was punched and had his belongings taken. A second victim was approached by Curtin, who became aggressive when refused. A third man intervened, and Curtin attempted to take his phone but was unsuccessful. The gardaí were alerted and Curtin was arrested. The court heard that Curtin's addiction to alcohol and drugs, as well as his mental health issues, were central to his offending. His defense argued for structured recovery programs. The judge adjourned the case for sentencing. The prosecution emphasized the need for Curtin to receive help, while the defense highlighted his willingness to remain drug-free. Joe Curtin pleaded guilty.
A Workplace Relations Commission adjudicator awarded a care worker €21,153.50 for unfair dismissal, ruling that the employer failed to follow adequate probation procedures during the appeal stage. The complainant alleged she was targeted for taking maternity leave and for reporting that her manager's brother was on holiday while on sick leave. She also claimed her manager made adverse comments regarding contraception and pregnancy, remarks the manager denied. The adjudicator found insufficient evidence to corroborate these specific allegations or to link the dismissal to protected grounds or disclosures. However, the tribunal concluded the dismissal was automatically unfair because the performance management process lacked outside involvement during a breakdown in the working relationship, and the subsequent appeal was cursory with unsatisfactory reasoning. The worker, hired in February 2023, failed her final probation review in January 2024. The adjudicator assessed her losses at over €40,000 but reduced the award by 50% due to a failure to mitigate losses. The decision was anonymised to protect vulnerable service users. Paul Gough of Beauchamps Solicitors represented the employer, while Cathy McGrady BL, instructed by Farrell McElwee Solicitors, represented the complainant.
The Court of Appeal has reduced the prison sentence of Ebenezer Oduntan, a former pastor of the City of David Church in County Kildare, from seven years to six years, with the final six months suspended. Oduntan was convicted of 87 theft and fraud-related offences following a three-week trial at Naas Circuit Criminal Court in March 2024. He had initially denied 54 charges but pleaded guilty midway through the trial to 19 counts of theft, five counts of deception, and nine charges of providing false information to the Companies Registration Office. The offences, spanning 2010 to 2020, involved embezzling approximately €125,000 from the church and inflating donation levels to claim larger tax rebates. Mr Justice Alexander Owens quashed the original sentence, describing the trial judge's headline sentence as "somewhat too high" but noting the offending was "particularly serious" due to a gross breach of trust. The judge highlighted that Oduntan made no restitution to the congregation or Revenue. While acknowledging limited mitigation, the Court of Appeal substituted the sentence with six years' imprisonment, suspending the final six months to encourage rehabilitation. The appeal was heard after Oduntan's legal team argued the original sentence was excessive given the total amount involved and his lack of previous convictions.
Joseph Lawlor was found guilty of murdering Michael Ryan by a Central Criminal Court jury, despite his claim that the stabbing was a coincidence. The jury rejected his self-defence argument after deliberating for eight hours and 57 minutes. Lawlor will be sentenced to life imprisonment next week. His second trial followed the collapse of the first due to late evidence disclosure and allegations of coaching a witness. During the trial, enhanced audio revealed Lawlor threatening Ryan, undermining his self-defence claim. CCTV and neighbour recordings showed multiple altercations between the men. Lawlor claimed he stabbed Ryan in self-defence after Ryan threatened to throw grenades through his windows. The jury did not accept his claim of reasonable force or honest belief in the need to attack Ryan.
A 70-year-old man has been sentenced to 20 years imprisonment at the Central Criminal Court for the systematic sexual abuse of five of his children over two decades at various addresses in County Sligo. Noel Farrell of Rathedmond Estate, Sligo, pleaded guilty to three counts of rape and 19 counts of indecent assault and sexual assault. The abuse included rape, sexual assault, and inappropriate touching of victims aged between two and seventeen. Evidence revealed that Farrell locked children in rooms for extended periods without food and forced them to drink urine. Mr Justice Tony Hunt described the case as "truly shocking" and noted the absence of mitigating factors beyond the guilty plea. He imposed a headline sentence of 30 years, reduced to 20 years. Four of the five victims waived anonymity to allow Farrell's identification. The judge commended the complainants for their fortitude in confronting their experiences. Farrell has been in custody since his guilty plea in November.
A man has failed to convince an appeal court that his conviction for "egregious" driving on the M50 was a case of mistaken identity and will be jailed for five months. Freddie Hegarty was convicted in the District Court of four counts of dangerous driving and was sentenced to five months imprisonment for the first count, along with a ten-year driving disqualification and a €1,000 fine. He later lodged an appeal against his conviction. Garda David Jordan testified that during a pursuit, Hegarty drove a BMW through a red light, accelerated hard, and cut off road users on the M50. He said that he saw the registration of the car and notified colleagues on the radio that there was a vehicle driving dangerously. Garda Jordan said that during the pursuit, which lasted for about 10 to 15 minutes, the car accelerated hard, veering left and right and cutting off road users. He said that the car went through a red light and eventually proceeded to Connolly Memorial Hospital.
A man has been given a suspended sentence after an automatic monitoring system alerted Google to the presence of 15 files of child abuse material in his cloud storage. Austin Odibei pleaded guilty to possession of child sexual abuse material in April 2019. Judge Orla Crowe sentenced him to 18 months, suspended for three years. The investigating garda outlined that Google notified the relevant authority in America in March 2019 about the suspected presence of CSAM on an individual's Google account. Gardai were notified and a Google account and mobile number were linked to the defendant. His home was searched in April 2019, and several devices, including a phone and a camera, were seized. Garda analysis of the devices recovered 13 files of CSAM, including eleven videos and two images, which were found on the memory card in the camera. Two further videos were found on the phone. The court heard that the victims were not identifiable.
Serial offender Ronaldo Otto, who goes by the name Samantha, has been jailed for five years after sexually assaulting a vulnerable autistic man. Otto, originally from the Philippines, was found guilty of sexually assaulting a 20-year-old autistic man on February 1, 2023, in a laneway in Dublin. The victim, who uses a disability card for the bus, was followed by Otto, who sat beside him and asked for his phone number. Otto then groped the victim and forced him down a laneway, where he performed oral sex on him. The victim reported the incident to his parents and attended the Sexual Assault Treatment Unit. CCTV footage and DNA evidence linked Otto to the crime. Otto had previously been given a suspended sentence for throwing boiling water on a man in 2019, but it was reactivated after he was convicted of another sexual assault in 2022. Judge Orla Crowe noted the victim was vulnerable due to his disability and described Otto's actions as predatory and intimidating.
A 40-year-old father of four has been jailed for four years for storing almost €100,000 worth of cocaine in his home and shed. Paul Dardis was before Dublin Circuit Criminal Court, charged with possession of drugs for sale or supply at his home on November 18, 2022. Garda Michael Leahy told the court that gardai carried out a planned search of Dardis's home that day and found a total of €99,169 worth of cocaine at various locations, including his kitchen and bedroom. Most of it was seized from a garden shed, along with mixing agents and €64 worth of heroin. Weighing scales were also found. Dardis later took full responsibility for all drugs found in his home. He said he was storing the cocaine in exchange for a reduction in his own personal drug debt. Gda Leahy agreed with Giollaíosa Ó Lideadha SC, defending, that both Dardis and his partner had mental health difficulties. He said that Dardis showed no signs of wealth and had not come to garda attention since.
A car salesman accused of theft for buying a customer's trade-in for a higher price in an "around the corner" deal has won €10,000 for unfair dismissal. The employee, Alex Collins, was fired in November 2024 by Cork City motor dealership Kevin O'Leary Silversprings Ltd, trading as the Kevin O'Leary Group. His complaint under the Unfair Dismissals Act 1977 was upheld by the Workplace Relations Commission in a decision published today. Mr Collins considered himself "a high-performing employee", as he had passed probation after joining in August 2023 and earned around €60,000 in 2024 prior to his dismissal – roughly doubling his basic annual salary of €30,000 with what he made on commission. Mr Collins came under scrutiny after a customer complained that he had been asked to park a car he intended trade-in "around the corner", company sales manager Dermot O'Sullivan said in evidence. The customer had called it "an unusual way of doing business", Mr O'Sullivan said. He said it "raised concerns about deviations from standard procedures".
A former British Army soldier, Noel Long (77), is seeking to have his life sentence for murder overturned, arguing that the evidence was insufficient to prove intent. Long, who has 31 previous convictions, was found guilty in August 2023 for the 1981 murder of Nora Sheehan, whose body was discovered in Shippool Woods, Co Cork. His legal team claims that the prosecution failed to prove that Long did more than assault the victim with slaps and punches to the head and face. They also argue that there was a prejudicial delay in bringing the case and that DNA evidence should not have been presented to the jury. During the appeal hearing, Long's legal team submitted that the trial judge, Mr Justice Paul McDermott, made errors in his charge to the jury regarding the definition of 'serious injury' and in not withdrawing the murder charge after the defense's evidence. The defense argues that the force described by the pathologist was not enough to prove intent to cause serious injury. Noel Long pleaded not guilty.
A jury will return to the Central Criminal Court to continue deliberations in the trial of Joseph Lawlor, who is accused of murdering his friend Michael Ryan in June 2024. Lawlor claims he acted in self-defence and to protect his property. The trial began in January, and the jury requested a copy of Lawlor's testimony, which detailed the events leading to the fatal stabbing. The jury heard that Lawlor and Ryan had been drinking and had multiple altercations throughout the evening. Ryan was arrested for drink driving and later returned to Lawlor's home, demanding the return of a watch and threatening to use "pineapples" (slang for grenades). Lawlor pursued Ryan to a carpark and stabbed him in the neck, causing his death. The judge instructed the jury that if they found Lawlor's account credible and that he used reasonable force, they must acquit. However, if he used excessive force, the verdict would be manslaughter. If the prosecution proved he did not act in self-defence, the verdict would be murder. Joseph Lawlor pleaded not guilty.
A 45-year-old man who slapped his eight-year-old son over toileting issues in 2018 has been jailed for two years and four months, with the final eight months suspended. The man pleaded guilty to child cruelty and assault causing harm. He has six previous convictions for domestic violence against the boy's mother. Judge Sinéad Ní Chúlacháin described the incident as a breach of parental trust and noted the psychological impact on the boy, who now experiences anxiety. The man self-reported the incident to authorities in 2019. The court heard that the boy's mother did not report the incident to Tusla, and photos of the boy's injuries were shown in court. The man, who represented himself, expressed that he believed the judge was fair and questioned the sentence length. The judge allowed him to appeal the sentence to the Court of Appeal.
A judge has expressed frustration with what he described as the 'triumph of bureaucracy and administration over actually doing something' during a murder trial. The accused, who was due to stand trial earlier this year, had his case adjourned due to concerns about his mental health. His barrister informed Mr Justice Tony Hunt that initial issues regarding pay rates for psychiatric reports had been resolved, with the Legal Aid Board agreeing to increase the rate from €120 to €300 per hour. However, a new obstacle has emerged, as the board now requires a PPS number for the accused before sanctioning a report. The accused's solicitor has been unable to obtain this number. Mr Justice Hunt stated that he could not 'micromanage affairs between solicitors and the Legal Aid Board' and emphasized that trials should not be delayed over trivialities like providing a PPS number. He called for action to be taken rather than bureaucratic delays. A barrister for the State said they would assist in finding the PPS number. The matter was adjourned to March for an update.
PJ Higgins, 47, pleaded guilty at Castlebar Circuit Court to assault causing harm to his brother, Michael Higgins, at their address in Cloongullaune, Swinford, Co Mayo, on July 27, 2022. The defendant admitted to hitting the victim over the head with a shovel, an act Judge Eoin Garavan noted could easily have been fatal. Michael Higgins was taken to Mayo University Hospital unconscious and bleeding, with a CT scan revealing fluid on the brain. He was discharged three days later but reported ongoing headaches, blurred vision, and fear for his life. The court heard the incident arose from an entrenched, longstanding family dispute. Judge Garavan delayed sentencing until the conclusion of two other cases against family members to ensure all background information was available. A probation report placed PJ Higgins at moderate risk of re-offending but noted he accepts responsibility and shows genuine remorse. The judge highlighted that the offence occurred the day before PJ Higgins was due to be sentenced for a previous threat to kill or cause serious harm, for which he served 12 months in custody. Defence counsel argued the act was impulsive rather than premeditated. The matter was adjourned to July 23 to finalise the sentence.
A 25-year-old Dublin man was sentenced to six years in prison, with the final 18 months suspended, for assaulting his pregnant partner and making threats against his ex-girlfriend. The man pleaded guilty to multiple charges, including assault causing harm and making threats to kill or cause serious harm. During the incident in August 2024, he punched, dragged, and kicked his pregnant partner in the stomach, knowing she was pregnant. He had previously been on bail for threatening to petrol bomb his ex-girlfriend's home. The court heard that he had a history of violent behavior, including breaches of protection orders and criminal damage. The victim, who was three months pregnant at the time of the assault, declined an ambulance and did not want to leave her children. The man was arrested after a five-day drugs bender and had a history of addiction. His defense highlighted his mental health issues and history of child sexual abuse, but the court emphasized the seriousness of the assault on a pregnant woman.
The Criminal Assets Bureau (CAB) was granted High Court permission to sell three high-end vehicles, a BMW M2, a BMW M3, and an Audi Q7, seized from former Real IRA member Nathan Kinsella. Barrister Daragh Breen BL, representing the CAB, described the cars as assets of "very high worth" and in depreciation. Mr Justice Liam Kennedy granted the application to appoint a CAB receiver to sell the vehicles, with proceeds to be held pending a substantive hearing. The matter was adjourned to next month. Kinsella, of Blackrock, Co Dublin, was not present. In 2024, Kinsella pleaded guilty to three counts of failing to furnish tax returns for capital acquisitions tax in 2018, 2019, and 2020. He was sentenced to one year in prison. Previously, in 2014, the Special Criminal Court sentenced him to two years for membership of an unlawful organisation styling itself the Irish Republican Army, otherwise Oglaigh na hEireann, otherwise the IRA, for acts committed on September 13, 2012. Kinsella has 17 previous convictions, including road traffic offences and impeding a prosecution.
A man who verbally abused gardai and resisted arrest on a Dublin street had his three-month jail term replaced with 180 hours of community service on appeal. Jason Prenderville, 35, was convicted of obstruction of a peace officer, threatening and abusive behavior, and being intoxicated in a public place. During the incident, he told gardai to leave him alone and had to be restrained on the ground. He has 73 previous convictions and was described as a nuisance by the judge. His defense noted that he now attends AA meetings and has a history of alcohol problems. The judge ruled that community service was more appropriate than imprisonment, emphasizing that Prenderville should abstain from alcohol. The appeal highlighted the severity of his previous convictions and the need for a more proportionate sentence.
Garry Nugent, a former events officer with Cycling Ireland, has been given an 18-month suspended sentence for submitting false quotations to secure sports grants. Nugent, 51, pleaded guilty to two charges of attempting to deceive the Department of Transport. He submitted fake quotations for grants intended to fund tandem bicycles for the Paralympics and timing equipment. Cycling Ireland did not receive the grants, and the charity suffered reputational damage and lost a sponsor. The court heard that Nugent was under pressure due to the pandemic and a tight deadline. Judge Orla Crowe acknowledged the exceptional circumstances but noted that Nugent played an active role in the deception. She imposed a suspended sentence with conditions, including good behavior for three years.
A Concern call centre manager, Lee Caluan, who claimed that bullying and harassment complaints against him were due to a 'Gen Z/woke alliance' at work, has lost a legal challenge to his sacking. Caluan told a tribunal that junior staff had 'turned the tables' on him due to a dislike of his management style, and that the complaints were 'riddled with inconsistencies'. He admitted to calling a colleague a 'b***h' during a workplace probe into bullying and harassment complaints from three different workers. His complaint under the Unfair Dismissals Act 1977 against Concern Worldwide was dismissed by the employment tribunal. Brian Joyce of IBEC, representing the charity, stated that the June 2024 dismissal followed a 'full and fair investigation'. An investigation concluded that Caluan had committed 'gross misconduct' for several breaches of the code of conduct and had violated the bullying and harassment policy. The probe followed a formal complaint in August 2023 from three telemarketing executives. An investigation manager noted that Caluan 'did not wish to engage' in the probe and 'declined any further investigations'.
A jury has begun deliberations in the murder trial of Joseph Lawlor, who claims he stabbed his friend, Michael Ryan, in self-defense. Lawlor, 39, pleaded not guilty to the murder of Ryan, who was found dead in a carpark after a dispute. The jury heard that Lawlor and Ryan had been drinking and had multiple altercations. Ryan returned to Lawlor's home after being released from custody for drink driving and accused Lawlor of calling gardai. Ryan threatened to bring others to attack Lawlor's home. Lawlor pursued Ryan to the carpark and stabbed him once in the neck, severing an artery. The judge instructed the jury that if Lawlor used reasonable force in self-defense, he must be acquitted. If the force was excessive, the verdict would be manslaughter. If the prosecution proved Lawlor did not act in self-defense, the verdict would be murder.
A deaf man was awarded €40,000 in compensation after being denied a job interview due to a lack of an academic qualification in Irish Sign Language (ISL). The National Council for Special Education (NCSE) was ruled to have indirectly discriminated against Noel O'Connell, who is a fluent ISL speaker and holds a PhD in deaf education. The tribunal found that requiring an academic qualification in ISL was discriminatory as it effectively excluded deaf people from the position. The NCSE had initially rejected O'Connell's application, stating he did not have the required qualification, despite being a native ISL user. A senior civil servant later reviewed the decision and found that O'Connell met the requirements, but the recruitment process had already closed. The tribunal ruled in favor of O'Connell, noting that the requirement for a formal academic qualification in ISL was a condition that disproportionately disadvantaged deaf applicants. The €13,000 compensation cap under Irish law was overturned, and the tribunal awarded €40,000 for the breach of the Employment Equality Act.
An unnamed man had his conviction for breaching a safety order overturned on appeal by the District Court Appeals Court. The appellant, who was originally convicted in the District Court on May 24, 2023, under section 33(1) of the Domestic Violence Act 2018, was fined €500 before lodging the appeal. The case involved allegations that he threatened his ex-partner during a child access collection. While the complainant and a prosecution witness testified that the man used threatening language, the appellant denied using such words, stating he was merely discussing the child's confusion. Defence counsel argued the evidence did not meet the criminal standard, highlighting conflicting accounts. Judge Gerard Meehan allowed the appeal, finding that the court could not be satisfied beyond doubt that the alleged words were used. The judge concluded that the evidence did not reach the criminal standard required for a conviction, resulting in the conviction being overturned.
Sabouni Abdelhamid, an Algerian man, has been jailed for three years for passport fraud after falsely claiming to be the son of an Irish woman murdered in the 1980s. He used multiple aliases and forged documents to obtain an Irish passport, including a French identification document and a utility bill. Abdelhamid was stopped at Dublin Airport in 2025 after discrepancies were found in his documents. He pleaded guilty to possession of a false instrument and providing misleading documentation. The court heard that Abdelhamid had a previous conviction under a different alias for a similar offence. Judge Orla Crowe noted the sophistication required to carry out the fraud and stated that a headline sentence of six years was warranted, but reduced it to three years due to mitigating factors, including Abdelhamid's guilty plea and his behavior in custody.
Cody Ferguson, a rail engineer, was jailed for five and a half years after being caught with nearly €350,000 worth of cannabis at Dublin Airport. He was arrested in August 2025 after customs officers found 34 packages of cannabis in his suitcase. Ferguson initially claimed he was on holiday in Thailand but later admitted to acting as a drugs courier to pay off a drug debt. He pleaded guilty to possessing cannabis for sale or supply. Ferguson has 11 previous convictions in the UK, including ten for drug offences. His defense highlighted his status as a qualified rail engineer and a father to a seven-month-old baby. Judge Martin Nolan reduced a headline sentence of nine years to five and a half years, taking into account Ferguson's early guilty plea and other mitigating factors.
Detective Garda Joseph Kavanagh used the Pulse system to print documents he believed were being concealed from the High Court in a case involving his partner, Sinead Warren. The case revolves around a search of Warren's home in Dublin 8 in 2016, which she alleges was a ruse to interfere in her personal life and relationship with Kavanagh. Kavanagh told the court he accessed the Pulse system to print draft information sheets related to the search warrant, which he believed were being withheld. The defense argued that the documents were unlawfully acquired and breached data protection laws. The court allowed the documents to be included in the case on grounds of fairness. Warren is seeking damages for alleged breaches of her constitutional rights, negligence, and deceit. The trial continues with further evidence expected next week.
Stephen Markham, a sexual assault survivor, has spoken out about the importance of being vocal if someone experiences a similar incident. He was sexually assaulted by Cezar Toader, an on-bail offender, who followed him home after they met in Dublin City Centre in 2020. Toader, who is part of the Roma community, was sentenced to four years in prison, with the final six months suspended. Markham waived his anonymity and shared his victim impact statement, detailing the emotional and psychological toll the assault had on him, including PTSD, anxiety, and depression. He expressed gratitude for the support he received from the community and gardai, and encouraged others to speak out if they are victims of similar crimes. The court heard that Toader had a history of previous convictions and was on bail at the time of the assault. Judge Orla Crowe acknowledged the courage of Markham in coming forward and noted the impact of the crime on the victim. Cezar Toader pleaded guilty.
The Court of Appeal was told it is a mystery how over 300 physical exhibits from the 1981 murder of Nora Sheehan were lost, including a vaginal swab that could have yielded further DNA evidence. Noel Long, now 77, was convicted of the murder in 2023 after a DNA match between semen found on the victim and DNA from his clothing. Long's defense argued that the 42-year delay in bringing the case breached his right to a fair and expeditious trial. They also claimed that the loss of exhibits, including the vaginal swab, prejudiced his case. The prosecution countered that the delay was not sufficient to presume prejudice and that the DNA evidence was crucial to the conviction. They emphasized that the case was not dropped in 1981 but was revived after a DNA breakthrough in 2008. The trial judge ruled that the delay was not enough to affect the fairness of the trial, and the prosecution argued that the evidence was compelling enough to secure a conviction despite the passage of time.